An insurance company saying you helped cause a car accident does not automatically settle the question of fault. The percentage assigned to you matters because Florida now follows a modified comparative-fault rule for applicable negligence cases.
Under current Florida law, compensation can be reduced according to your percentage of responsibility. More importantly, a person found greater than 50% at fault for their own harm generally cannot recover damages in an applicable negligence action.
At The Black Law Company, we believe a serious fault dispute should be investigated using evidence—not decided solely from an adjuster’s first impression of the crash.
Key Takeaways
- Florida allows responsibility for a collision to be divided among multiple parties.
- Your damages can be reduced by your percentage of fault.
- Being found more than 50% responsible can bar recovery in an applicable negligence action.
- An insurer’s initial fault assessment is not necessarily the final legal determination.
- Evidence such as video, photographs, witness accounts, and vehicle damage can change how a crash is evaluated.
How Does Florida’s Comparative-Fault Rule Work?
Florida Statute §768.81 provides that a claimant’s damages are reduced in proportion to the fault assigned to that claimant.
Consider a simplified example.
Suppose your damages are determined to be $100,000. If you are found 20% responsible for causing your own harm, the recoverable damages would generally be reduced by 20%.
The stakes become much higher around the 50% line. Florida law states that a party found greater than 50% at fault for their own harm may not recover damages in an applicable negligence case.
This makes accurate fault analysis especially important when insurers disagree about how a collision happened.
What If Both Drivers Made a Mistake?
More than one person can contribute to the same crash.
For example, another driver might make an unsafe lane change while an insurer argues that you were speeding. A driver could turn in front of you while claiming you were distracted and failed to react quickly enough.
Those facts cannot be resolved by simply saying, “both drivers were partly at fault.”
The questions are how each person’s conduct contributed to the crash and what the evidence supports.
What Evidence Can a Car Accident Lawyer Examine?
A car accident lawyer can investigate the collision independently rather than relying only on an insurer’s version of events.
Depending on the case, useful evidence may include:
- Photographs and video from the crash scene
- Vehicle damage patterns
- Witness statements
- Dash-camera footage
- Nearby surveillance footage
- Traffic-signal information
- Crash reports
- Medical documentation
- Electronic vehicle information when available
Evidence can also disappear.
Businesses may overwrite surveillance video, vehicles may be repaired, and witnesses may become difficult to locate. That is one reason early investigation can matter even though a lawsuit may not be filed immediately.
What If the Police Report Says I Was at Fault?
A crash report can be important evidence, but it does not necessarily decide civil liability by itself.
Insurance companies and attorneys may consider the report alongside witness accounts, physical evidence, photographs, video, and other information.
At The Black Law Company, our car-accident practice includes investigating liability disputes and gathering evidence when fault is challenged. Our firm represents car-accident victims in Tampa and throughout Florida.
You should therefore avoid assuming that an initial statement about fault is the last word.
Why Does the Percentage of Fault Matter So Much?
Because small differences can have large financial consequences.
Someone assessed at 20% fault faces a different situation from someone assessed at 55%. At more than 50%, Florida’s statutory rule can prevent recovery in an applicable negligence action altogether.
Fault also interacts with other questions, including the amount of damages, available insurance, the severity of injuries, and whether multiple parties contributed to the collision.
A strong case evaluation looks at those issues together.
FAQ
Can I recover compensation if I am exactly 50% at fault?
Florida’s statute states that a party greater than 50% at fault may not recover damages in an applicable negligence action. A claimant assessed at exactly 50% is not barred by that specific provision, although damages would generally be reduced according to the claimant’s percentage of fault.
Should I accept the insurance company’s percentage of fault?
You do not necessarily have to accept an insurer’s initial assessment. Evidence may support a different allocation of responsibility.
Have a Tampa Car Accident Lawyer Review the Evidence
The Black Law Company handles Florida car-accident claims involving disputed liability, insurance issues, injuries, and financial losses. From our Tampa office, we provide free case evaluations to people who need help understanding what comes next after a crash.
This post was written by Okoye Morgan Jr., a lawyer with extensive knowledge as a car accident attorney Tampa FL. Okoye is one of the founding partners of The Black Law Company, specializing in personal injury law, trust and estate law, civil litigation law, and criminal defense.
The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice. All information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information. This website contains links to other third-party websites. Such links are only for the convenience of the reader, user or browser; the ABA and its members do not recommend or endorse the contents of the third-party sites.